The lucky (or skillful!) winners are listed out below.
It covering the overall winners from 1995 to 2002 and more detail from 2002 to present day by winner, runner-up, monthly winners and cup winners.
| Hall of Fame 2007/08 | |
| Category | Name |
| Overall Winner | Colin Rigby |
| Runner Up | Ryan Moody |
| League Cup | Tim Owen |
| FA Cup | Austin Kershaw |
| August '07 | Rob Bushell |
| September '07 | Rob Bushell |
| October '07 | Colin Rigby |
| November '07 | Colin Rigby and Ryan Moody (Joint) |
| December '07 | Ryan Moody |
| January '08 | Russ Fanham |
| February '08 | Dan Owen |
| March '08 | Austin Kershaw |
| April/May '08 | Dan Owen |
View final results table for 2007/08
| Hall of Fame 2006/07 | |
| Category | Name |
| Overall Winner | Paul Keech (2nd) |
| Runner Up | Shaun Moody |
| League Cup | Patrick Williams |
| FA Cup | Graham Highton |
| August/September '06 | John/Phil Kelly |
| October '06 | Paul Keech |
| November '06 | Jimmy Lyons |
| December '06 | Jimmy Lyons |
| January '07 | Simon Baldwin |
| February '07 | Tim Owen |
| March '07 | Shaun Moody |
| April/May '07 | Ian Cowburn |
| Hall of Fame 2005/06 | |
| Category | Name |
| Overall Winner | Tim Owen (3rd) |
| Runner Up | Simon Baldwin |
| League Cup | Simon Baldwin |
| FA Cup | Paul Keech / Lynne Stokoe |
| September '05 | Alex Hampson |
| October '05 | Colin Rigby |
| November '05 | Rob Bushell |
| December '05 | Matt/Dan Owen |
| January '06 | Alan Keech |
| February '06 | Matt Hall |
| March '06 | Rhys Jones |
| April/May '06 | Rhys Jones |
| Best Original Team | Graham Highton |
| Hall of Fame 2004/05 | |
| Category | Name |
| Overall Winner | Simon Waller |
| Runner Up | Russ Farnham |
| League Cup | Simon Waller |
| FA Cup | Rob Bushell |
| August '04 | Lesley Rigby |
| September '04 | Pete Histon |
| October '04 | Rhys Jones |
| November '04 | Russ Farnham |
| December '04 | Chris/Peter Gerrard |
| January '05 | Simon Waller |
| February '05 | Simon Waller |
| March '05 | Rob Bushell |
| April/May '05 | Pete Whitehead |
| Hall of Fame 2003/04 | |
| Category | Name |
| Overall Winner | Stu Jones |
| Runner Up | Rhys Jones |
| League Cup | Jimmy Yates |
| FA Cup | Tim Owen |
| August '03 | Matt/Dan Owen |
| September '03 | Paul Leech |
| October '03 | Tim Owen |
| November '03 | Barbara Lindsay |
| December '03 | Rhys Jones |
| January '04 | Rhys Jones |
| February '04 | Paul Keech |
| March '04 | Matt Hall |
| April/May '04 | Jenkins/Stokoe |
| Hall of Fame 2002/03 | |
| Category | Name |
| Overall Winner | Ken Trainer (2nd) |
| Runner Up | Jimmy Yates |
| August '02 | Dave Mather |
| September '02 | Pete Whitehead |
| October '02 | Stu Jones |
| November '02 | Ken Trainer |
| December '02 | Dave Mather |
| January '03 | Pete Whitehead |
| February '03 | Paul Gerrard |
| March '03 | Paul Keech |
| April/May '03 | Jimmy Yates |
| Hall of Fame (Early Years) | |
| Year | Winner |
| 2001/2002 | Mark Jones |
| 2000/2001 | Alan Keech |
| 1999/2000 | Tim Owen (2nd) |
| 1998/1999 | Paul Keech |
| 1997/1998 | Russ Farnham |
| 1996/1997 | Ken Trainer |
| 1995/1996 | Tim Owen |
| 1994/1995 | Lynne Stokoe |
